If Jim Crow returns, America will lose more than its democracy — it will lose its soul

Dr. Barbara Reynolds argues that if Jim Crow returns, America will lose more than democracy, warning that attacks on Black voting rights echo the brutal post-Reconstruction era.

Picture of Barbara Reynolds

Barbara Reynolds

Dr. Barbara Reynolds

TriceEdneyWire.com — When Rep. James Clyburn recently warned that America risks sliding backward toward the post-Reconstruction era, many heard the words but failed to grasp the horror behind them.

They should.

The soft-spoken South Carolina congressman is not given to exaggeration. When Clyburn invokes the specter of post-Reconstruction America, he is not quoting a distant chapter from a textbook. He is warning of a period so brutal, so morally disfiguring, that its scars remain visible in the American landscape more than a century later.

His warning came after he narrowly survived a congressional redistricting battle pushed by the Supreme Court and President Trump. It threatened to erase the district he represents. Had it succeeded, about 1.4 million Black South Carolinians would have been left without a single Black member of Congress representing them.

For many, redistricting can seem like a technical debate over maps and voting boundaries. But his choice of words should not be whitewashed. Gentle one-liners or mellifluous phrases won’t do. The headlines should be blood-soaked, screaming and explosive.

Clyburn’s warning reminds us of the terrible tyranny after slavery ended.

 After the Civil War, America entered Reconstruction which lasted from about 1865 to 1877. For the first time, nearly four million formerly enslaved people were recognized as citizens rather than property. They could finally be treated as humans owning their own bodies.

The passage of the 13th amendment abolished slavery. The 14th granted citizenship. Although millions had been enslaved since 1619, the 15th protected voting rights for Black men.

Those legal actions produced remarkable results:  Black Americans voted. They organized. They built businesses, churches, schools, and communities. More than 1,500 African Americans held public office. Twenty served in the U.S. House of Representatives. Two served in the U.S. Senate.

Then came the backlash.

The U.S. Supreme Court aided and abetted a rising anti-black campaign to dispel Black political advancement. The most egregious case was the 1857 Dred Scott decision delivered by Chief Justice Roger B. Taney  ruling Blacks had no rights that Whites had to respect. In 1896, the high court’s Plessy V. Ferguson decision legalized racial segregation.

Without the protection of the legal system, the KKK and White vigilantes conducted a reign of terror, because it was no longer against the law to murder Blacks. In fact, more than 6,500 Blacks were lynched according to the Equal Justice Institute from 1830 to 1950. It was not unusual for pastors to pause church services for their congregants to watch the lynchings of Black people. Then they returned to church observances as if nothing inhumane had happened.

Incidents like the Tulsa massacre of 1921 were not unusual. A White mob attacked the prosperous Black neighborhood of Greenwood in Tulsa, Oklahoma, destroying homes and businesses.   About 300 Blacks died there.

Courts weakened civil rights protections. States erected barriers to voting. Poll taxes, literacy tests, grandfather clauses, and intimidation campaigns transformed constitutional rights into empty promises.     

Legal segregation meant Blacks were forced to suffer the indignity of Jim Crow laws which mandated they could not play cards or checkers with Whites or participate in integrated sports.  They had to enter White restaurants through back doors and be off the streets at sundown. Schools, parks, movies, hotels were segregated. When they died, Blacks were buried in segregated graves.

Today, similar circumstances disenfranchising Black people are arising. The Supreme Court recently passed legislation that virtually gutted the rights of Black voters.

In addition, President Trump has instituted an anti-Black campaign that suggests the return of the ‘post Reconstruction Period’ by firing Black leaders,  dismantling civil rights protections, the gutting of federal jobs that helped build the Black middle class and canceling diversity programs that aided Black colleges. In fact, 300,000 jobs held by Black women were terminated last year.

In the wake of falling election poll numbers, Trump officials are ordering GOP leaders in Southern states to gerrymander voter districts to curtail Black voters who are key to the Democrats’ base.

That is why Clyburn’s warning deserves attention.

He recounts in his book, The First Eight, how eight Black men from South Carolina were elected to Congress during the Post Reconstruction era. Yet within a decade, a combination of violence, voter suppression, and legal barriers drove them from office. It would take nearly a century before another Black South Carolinian (James Clyburn himself) would be elected to Congress in 1992.

As the doors of democracy begin to close again, we must remember: What is taken from one group is taken from us all.

If America returns to the spirit of Jim Crow, the greatest loss will not be Black political representation alone. It will be the moral core of the nation itself.

And as Clyburn warns, some damage would take generations to undo.

Leave a Reply

Your Tennessee State Museum Celebrates Juneteenth and hosts a Special Author Event June 13

The Tennessee State Museum celebrates Juneteenth on June 19 with musical guests, Sankofa African Drum and Dance Company at noon, Storytime, crafts, and hands-on history

Eastpoint Flats breaks ground as first fully affordable housing development on Nashville’s East Bank

Eastpoint Flats breaks ground as the first 100% affordable housing development on Nashville’s East Bank, delivering 323 apartments, a childcare center, and retail space backed

‘A Road She Traveled to Fight for the People’: Clarksville Pike Dedicated as Sen. Thelma Harper Parkway

Clarksville Pike was renamed Sen. Thelma Harper Parkway in North Nashville, honoring the first Black woman elected to the Tennessee Senate and her nearly 30-year

Expressions of faith: Grace of God

Bishop-Elect Dr. Monterey D. Lee, Sr. teaches that salvation is God’s gracious gift, urging believers to use their gifts, pray, love one another, and live

There’s no ‘moral’ death penalty

Furonda Brasfield argues there’s no moral death penalty, as nitrogen gas executions and Arkansas’s history of racial terror show the state’s search for a “humane”