Stephen A. Smith calls NABJ award a ‘personal hit job’

Stephen A. Smith pushes back after receiving NABJ’s Thumbs Down award, disputing claims of disparaging commentary about Black women and calling the decision a personal hit job.

Stephen A. Smith in 2023 (photo courtesy of Moody College of Communication).

ATLANTA, Ga. — ESPN commentator Stephen A. Smith is pushing back against the National Association of Black Journalists after the organization gave him its ‘Thumbs Down’ award, accusing him of a pattern of disparaging commentary about prominent Black women.

Smith received the award Saturday during NABJ’s convention in Atlanta. The organization gives the designation to individuals or organizations whose commentary, reporting or practices conflict with its mission and values.

NABJ said: “Smith has established a recurring public pattern of disparaging commentary directed at prominent Black women across politics, sports and media,” the organization said.

“Such commentary reinforces harmful narratives, undermines the fair and respectful representation of Black women in public discourse and stands in direct conflict with NABJ’s longstanding commitment to accurate, responsible and inclusive portrayals of Black communities.”

Smith responded Monday during a lengthy address on his YouTube channel, calling the award politically motivated and personally insulting.

“I’ve received a lot of insults in my day, but that might be the lowest,” Smith said.

Smith has drawn criticism for comments about several prominent Black women, including former Vice President Kamala Harris; former first lady, Michelle Obama; U.S. Rep. Jasmine Crockett; and tennis star Serena Williams. Smith, however, rejected the suggestion that his criticism reflects hostility toward Black women.

“Everything I am, everything that I have achieved, everything that has lifted me up in my life has been associated with Black women,” Smith said. “They have been my strength, my source of inspiration and so much more my entire life.”

Smith also accused NABJ leadership of failing to contact him before presenting the award and described the decision as a “personal hit job.” NABJ disputed his account, saying President Errin Haines welcomed an opportunity to speak privately with Smith and had not ruled out a later public discussion.

NABJ said the award is intended to encourage accountability rather than permanently condemn its recipients.

“Accountability should create an opportunity for reflection, dialogue and progress,” the organization said, adding that it remains open to “meaningful engagement” with Smith and the other recipients.

Despite his criticism, Smith urged his audience not to turn against the organization.

“Please continue to support the NABJ,” he said.

Leave a Reply

Federal lawsuit alleges Nashville Sen. Charlane Oliver’s free speech rights violated

Nashville Sen. Charlane Oliver and four constituents sue Senate Speaker Randy McNally, alleging retaliation over her protest of Tennessee’s congressional redistricting map.

School choice sparking Black parenting debate

Nikole Hannah-Jones’ essay about her daughter’s Brooklyn school choice sparks debate over public education, integration and what Black parents owe their children.

Civil rights groups sue over threat of federal agents at polls

The NAACP, National Urban League and allied groups sue to block ICE and other federal agents near polling places, citing voter-intimidation concerns.

Federal appeals court strikes down Tennessee abortion ‘recruitment’ provision

The Sixth Circuit struck down Tennessee’s abortion “recruitment” provision, finding it violated First Amendment rights by restricting speech about legal out-of-state abortions.

Pressley calls for federal jobs guarantee as Black unemployment draws concern

Rep. Ayanna Pressley renews her call for a federal job guarantee as Black unemployment remains higher than White unemployment and Black women face acute financial