Before a school closes, show families the plan

Before closing schools in districts like Memphis-Shelby and Knox County, school boards must publish clear impact statements showing families transition plans and taxpayers the true financial savings.

Picture of J.C. Bowman

J.C. Bowman

J.C. Bowman

Closing a school changes a child’s bus ride, classroom, support services, and daily routine. Before voting to close a school, boards should show families what comes next and tell taxpayers how much the decision will actually save.

In February, the Memphis-Shelby County school board voted to close five schools before the 2026–27 school year, including one being transferred to another district. The district’s facilities plan contemplated as many as 15 closures by 2028. According to Chalkbeat Tennessee, about one in four district schools was using less than 60% of its available seats, while the district faced more than $1 billion in building repairs over the next decade.

Memphis is not alone. In Knox County, district leaders have discussed closing four elementary schools, changing school start times, and reducing bus routes as they confront budget pressures. Here in Nashville, the school board approved four closures in 2020, projecting approximately $3.4 million in annual savings. Whether those savings were fully realized deserves a clear public accounting.

When enrollment falls, an under-used building still needs heat, a sound roof, and regular maintenance. Money spent keeping it open is money unavailable for instruction and student services. Closing a school can save money, but the transition has costs of its own. Districts may face higher transportation expenses, upgrades at receiving schools, staffing changes, and security costs for vacant buildings. The public deserves to see both sides of the ledger.

The pressure is national. An Associated Press analysis with Stanford University’s Big Local News reported 1,156 school closures during the 2025–26 school year, the most since the pandemic. Yet Tennessee’s circumstances vary considerably. A growing community may need more classrooms while another district struggles to maintain aging buildings for fewer students. Even within the same district, enrollment patterns can differ.

The right decision depends on local facts, not statewide averages. Before a vote, boards should publish enrollment trends, repair estimates, projected savings, and alternatives considered for each school. Families should know where students will go, how transportation will work, and which programs will be available. They need meaningful opportunities to raise concerns before decisions become final.

Tennessee should establish a standard school-closure impact statement that districts make public before any final vote.

It should explain projected savings, transportation changes, receiving-school capacity, staffing implications, special education services, and the expected effect on student learning.

It should also identify how the district will measure results after the closure.

This is not another bureaucratic exercise.

It is a practical way to ensure school boards and communities have the same information before making decisions that cannot easily be reversed.

A bus route can look reasonable on a map and still require a child to leave home before daylight. A receiving school may have enough seats on paper but lack adequate classroom space, specialized staff, or necessary services.

Educators must be part of that conversation. Teachers and para-professionals understand the students, programs, and daily realities that spreadsheets cannot capture. Principals need staffing assignments early enough to build schedules. Employees deserve timely information about their assignments and opportunities to provide input. These are not details to address after a closure vote.

In Vallejo, California, the Associated Press reported that a parent questioned why her son’s disability records had not followed him to his new school. Such problems should never be discovered on the first day of class. Districts must confirm that student records are transferred, special education services are ready, and receiving schools have the personnel and resources to meet students’ needs.

Taxpayers also deserve a plain-English accounting. Put projected savings from utilities and maintenance alongside transportation expenses, building upgrades, personnel costs, and the expense of maintaining vacant properties. Separate one-time costs from ongoing savings. Explain when the district expects to break even and how the savings will benefit students.

If the goal is to protect classroom services or close a budget gap, say so directly. If a building will remain empty, explain what happens next. Then come back a year later and report the results.

Did savings match projections? How long are students spending on buses? Did attendance improve or decline? How many displaced students remained in the district? Are students receiving the services they were promised? Did the receiving schools deliver the educational opportunities used to justify consolidation?

A public report would help families judge whether the decision worked and give school boards better information before considering another closure.

A school is more than a building. It can be a neighborhood anchor, a place where generations of families learned and teachers built their careers. Those relationships matter. A board can respect that history and still conclude that consolidation is necessary.

But closing a school should never be mistaken for improving education. That requires a separate plan, measurable results, and a willingness to be held accountable.

School leaders have a duty to use public dollars wisely and provide every child with a school where they can learn. Fiscal responsibility and educational responsibility are not competing obligations. Both belong in the same decision.

Before closing a school, demonstrate that students will be served better, or at least no worse, and that taxpayers will receive the savings they were promised.

Show families the plan for their children. Show taxpayers the math.

(J.C. Bowman is the executive director of Professional Educators of Tennessee.)

Leave a Reply

Remembering Wamsutta Frank James on the National Day of Mourning

Learn about Wampanoag activist Frank "Wamsutta" James, his 1970 suppressed speech, and the annual National Day of Mourning held on Thanksgiving at Cole's Hill in

Tennessee voters overwhelmingly support property tax caps, oppose stadium subsidies

A new Beacon Poll shows 88% of Tennessee voters support property tax caps and 55% oppose stadium subsidies, alongside divided views on tariffs, surveillance cameras,

Oracle breaks ground on Nashville headquarters, promising jobs and East Bank transformation

Tech giant Oracle breaks ground on its sprawling 78-acre global headquarters along Nashville's East Bank, bringing thousands of jobs, infrastructure investments, and a Nobu hotel

Scott Colom makes history with stunning Mississippi Senate victory

Democrat Scott Colom defeats Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith in a historic upset, becoming the first Black U.S. senator elected by Mississippi voters since Reconstruction.

Emanuel Nine Memorial opens in South Carolina, honoring victims of 2015 church massacre

More than 11 years after the tragic 2015 shooting, the permanent Emanuel Nine Memorial opens in downtown Charleston, honoring the nine victims and celebrating the